Astrophysicists believe our galaxy must be filled with more dark matter than ordinary matter. Now, astronomers say they can find no evidence of dark matter’s gravitational influence on the planets. What gives?
Astronomers have a problem. Whenever they study the large scale structure of the universe, it soon becomes clear that the amount of visible matter cannot possibly generate enough gravity to hold together the structures they can see. Things like galaxy clusters and even galaxies themselves ought to fly apart given the amount of ordinary matter they contain.
Something else must be holding these things together. So astronomers have dreamed up the idea of dark matter — mysterious, invisible and non-interacting stuff that fills the universe, generating the gravity necessary to hold everything together.
This isn’t a small problem requiring a tiny amount of extra mass. The problem is huge. According to the latest picture of the large-scale structure of the Universe from the Planck space mission, ordinary visible matter makes up just 5% of the total mass/energy of the Universe whereas dark matter makes up 27%. The rest is the even more mysterious dark energy.
To make the numbers work, astrophysicists tell us that our galaxy ought to be at least 80% dark matter.
That means our Solar System must be swimming in the stuff. Indeed, physicists have calculated that particles of dark matter ought to slam into each human on the planet at a rate of 100,000 times a year, as we saw last year.
But that raises an important question. If we’re plowing through a thick sea of dark matter as astrophysicists suggest, why don’t we see evidence of it?
Most dark matter detectors work by looking for evidence of the collisions that dark matter must make with ordinary matter. A few of these experiments say they have found tentative evidence of these collisions.
But there is another way to look for dark matter: by observing its gravitational effects on the Solar System itself. If the Sun is surrounded by a thick soup of dark matter, we ought to be able to see its gravitational influence on the orbits of the planets, moons and asteroids.
Nikolay Pitjev at St. Petersburg State University and Elena Pitjeva at the Institute of Applied Astronomy in St Petersburg, both in Russia, have used the most detailed set of measurements of planetary orbits ever made to study this question. Their conclusion is that the gravitational effect of dark matter on the solar system is negligible.
Pitjev and Pitjeva have compiled an impressive data set consisting of some 677,000 measurements of planetary positions taken since 1910. These include optical measurements from observatories on Earth, ranging measurements from various spacecraft such as Cassini at Saturn and the Mars and Venus Express missions plus various Russian radar measurements of planetary positions taken between 1961 and 1995.
This data has become increasingly accurate in recent years. For example, the data from Cassini gives its distance at Saturn to within a meter or so.
Astrophysicists have used these measurements to model the behavior of the solar system, taking into account the perturbations caused by the major planets, the Moon, the 301 largest asteroids, the other asteroids modeled as a uniform ring, the 21 largest trans-Neptunian objects and so on.
Having taken all this into account, Pitjev and Pitjeva looked for anomalous gravitational effects that might be the result of dark matter. “If dark matter is present in the Solar system, then it should lead to some additional gravitational inﬂuence on all bodies,” they say.
The puzzling news is that Pitjev and Pitjeva find no evidence of this stuff in their analysis. If it is there, its effect must be smaller than the errors in the data.
Indeed, to satisfy this limit, they calculate that the amount of dark matter within the orbit of Saturn must be tiny. “The dark matter mass in the sphere within Saturn’s orbit should be less than 1.7 10^−10M⊙,” they say. That’s about the mass of a large asteroid.
So astronomers are left scratching their heads. On the one hand, they say dark matter must hold our galaxy together with a vice-like gravitational grip. On the other, its gravitational effect on the Solar System is negligible.
The contradictory effects of dark matter on different scales are fast turning into the most fascinating and urgent problem in physics and astronomy.
Researchers are currently spending big bucks to design, build and run giant experiments looking for dark matter in our vicinity. And yet the evidence already gathered from other sources, like Pitjev and Pitjeva, suggests that this investment may produce a very poor return.
That won’t stop them from looking.
Image courtesy of NASA
- What Obama Meant by Converting Sunlight into Liquid Fuel
- Microsoft Researchers Get Wrapped Up in Smart Scarf
- Drones That Can Suck Up Water Hunt Oil Leaks, Invasive Species
- Hawaii’s Solar Push Strains the Grid
This article originally published at MIT Technology Review